EC Fans... Why The Hot Air?

by Craig P

EC Fans... Why The Hot Air?

As technology advances and energy prices keep rising, it's inevitable that growers are starting looking for ways to improve the overall efficiency of their grows. As we saw with the HPS to LED revolution, we're now witnessing a similar movement from AC fans to EC fans. If you're wondering what all the hot air is about, keep reading below and we'll break things down for you!

 

What's the main difference between AC and EC fans?

When it comes to powering a fan motor, there are two main electrical delivery methods available: AC and DC. In simple terms, AC motors use a more basic technology that draws directly from the AC plug power source, while DC (EC fan) motors use an inbuilt transformer to convert AC to DC. For AC motors, speed is regulated by a resistor that is relatively unstable and inefficient. For DC fans, the power delivered to the motor is directly regulated by an EC (electronically commuted) controller, making the whole process much more efficient.

 

So which is better?

Based on what we've said so far, you'd be correct in thinking that DC motors are generally superior to AC. The delivery of power to the motor via DC is much more effective and efficient than with AC and the irregular forces applied to AC motors accelerate wear on the parts over time, while causing a buzz/hum (that's energy that could be used for rotational force being lost to sound). Furthermore, AC motors will continue to draw maximum power regardless of how fast they're spinning, while the power that DC motors use will be directly proportional to the speed selected - meaning that genuine energy savings can be had by reducing fan speed where possible.

  

What size should I get?

As a rough guide, for grow areas 1m squared and under, a 4" EC fan will handily take care of all but the most energy intense set-ups. If you've got a 1.2m x 1.2m tent, we'd recommend using a 6" EC fan. 1.5m x 1.5m tents should use at least 8". When it comes to getting the most out of any EC fan in your space, it's always better to oversize the fan and run at a lower speed setting. The advantage of this is that you'll see an improved lifespan and experience quieter operation, while also giving yourself extra power for when you need it - for example during a heatwave or if you decide to upsize your grow space.

 

Which brand of EC fan is best?

Here at www.ledgrowlights.co.uk, we only stock quality fans from reputable brands. Which brand suits you best will come down to your own list of requirements and priorities.

If you want your fan with a speed controller that can regulate speed based on either temperature or humidity parameters, there are plenty of options out there. The AC Infinity Cloudline range paired with a Controller 67 is a great entry level choice, being among the cheapest out there to possess these features. The Controller 67 has the added benefit of being able to control two fans from a single controller, so if you've got two spaces side by side or are using one fan as an intake and one as an outtake, you'll be able to do all that from a single controller - just be aware that they'll both be running from a single probe and on the same speed setting, so if you want to maintain negative pressure you'll need to match your extraction fan with a smaller intake.

 

AC Infinity 4" with Controller 67

 

 

The Mammoth Juiced Pro are a new-to-market high quality, aluminium housed EC fan range that will fit in all but the tightest spaces. The 4" Mammoth Juiced Pro is a beautifully sleek, small-yet-powerful EC fan perfect for stealth cabs and hobby grows, and the larger fans are amongst the smallest out there for their respective diameters.

 

Mammoth Juiced Pro 4"

 

Are EC Fans Quieter than AC Fans?

While it's true that EC fans are significantly quieter than AC equivalents, we need to keep these claims in perspective when considering a purchase based on reducing noise levels. Most of the unnecessary noise generated by AC fans comes from the buzz/hum associated with the inefficient transformer, so the advantage from EC fans is greater at lower speeds. When it comes to full speed operation, much of the noise generated by both AC and EC duct fans will come from the exhaust turbulence. As mentioned previously, if minimising noise is a top priority you're always better off getting the largest fan possible and operating at a slower speed. However, in order to deal with the noise from airflow, you'll need to actively dampen this turbulence. This is where silenced fans come into their own.

With a layer of acoustic foam built into the fan's housing, the noise generated by air flow is significantly lower with 'silent' acoustic fans like the EC Flo. The EC motor and acoustic foam combination drastically minimises any noises coming from your extraction with some of the higher end silenced EC fans such as the Mountain Air Whisper Fan taking the quality of the acoustic foam to the next level, achieving genuinely remarkable levels of soundproofing. 

 

 

EC Flo showing acoustic foam inside

Mountain Air Whisper

 

Conclusion

So if you want a decent quality, low priced EC fan with features only found with more expensive speed controllers, get yourself an AC Infinity with controller 67. If you want maximum power in minimum space, then the Mammoth Juiced Fans are best for you. If you want the quietest extraction possible then oversize the fan or get a silenced acoustic version alongside some quality ducting - or even better, combine both principles for the maximum effect.

With EC motors now taking over from older AC technology, we don't think it'll be long before they become the new standard for fan motors everywhere. If efficiency, noise, power and adaptability are top priorities for you when purchasing an extraction fan, then you really can't beat EC technology.